
Last month, New York’s attorney general pushed back in a court filing against a lawsuit challenging the state’s Medical Aid in Dying Act.
In Carmelite Sisters for the Aged and Infirm, Inc. v. James, Catholic-affiliated healthcare groups sued Attorney General Letitia James and New York state. They argue the law violates their religious freedom, much like claims made in other similar lawsuits.
But as James notes in her October 19 brief defending the Medical Aid in Dying Act, New York’s law already protects providers and facilities that do not want to prescribe medical aid in dying medication.
At Compassion & Choices, we believe those protections should not become permission to silence your doctor or make delaying care the reason your legal choice disappears.
The NY Attorney General’s office is unequivocal in their defense of the New York Medical Aid in Dying Act: “Plaintiffs incorrectly interpret the Medical Aid in Dying Act and Palliative Care Information Act to impose obligations on them that simply do not exist in the law and otherwise ask the Court to place their religious beliefs above terminally ill New Yorkers’ right to choose to die on their own terms.”
For James, this means the plaintiffs lack “standing,” or, in other words, any evidence that the law is actually harming them or could harm them.
For example, under New York’s law, a facility that chooses not to provide medical aid in dying must transfer a patient who asks for the option. The plaintiffs argue that this is a violation of their First Amendment rights. But as James points out, a transfer is not the same as being forced to take part in medical aid in dying; it simply respects the patient’s choice to get lawful care somewhere else.
The plaintiffs also claim that the law compels them to provide a particular perspective on medical aid in dying. But, James writes, nothing in the law does that. All religious facilities and providers are free to express their opinions however they see fit.
At the end of life, you deserve the truth, and your choices should belong to you.
This lawsuit challenges that idea. What’s at stake?
The Attorney General’s defense of the law is clear: the Medical Aid in Dying Act upholds religious freedom, does not compel participation or speech in violation of the First Amendment, and supports patient autonomy at the end of life.
Meanwhile, a temporary injunction in this case means that for now, qualifying New Yorkers who access care via Catholic hospital systems are unlikely to receive information about medical aid in dying and will have even more difficulty accessing the full range of end-of-life care.
Our team is working closely with doctors and other healthcare professionals to combat that and support successful implementation of this law in New York. We are helping patients and families who face barriers to care, including difficulty finding willing providers or obtaining medical records.
Compassion Legal is also actively investigating all reported delays and denials of care to help identify and address barriers to access. Together, these efforts are helping ensure that medical aid in dying is not just a right protected by law, but a meaningful option for eligible patients who need it.
Mail contributions directly to:
Compassion & Choices Gift Processing Center
PO Box 485
Etna, NH 03750
Compassion & Choices is a 501 C3 organization. Federal tax number: 84-1328829