John Radcliffe, a resident of Honolulu, Hawai’i, was diagnosed with cancer in 2014. While he has been fortunate enough to keep the cancer at bay since diagnosis, John would like the ability to receive a prescription for medical aid in dying in the event that his condition would worsen and he receive a terminal prognosis of less than six months. Dr. Charles Miller, stated that he would be willing to write the prescription, but that he could not due to his fear of being criminally prosecuted.
On January 11, 2017, John Radcliffe, Charles Miller, M.D., and Compassion & Choices (“Plaintiffs”) filed a Complaint which sought to clarify that Medical Aid in Dying was authorized in Hawaii and protected by the Hawaii constitution. The suit also sought to clarify two letter opinions written by Attorney General David Louie in 2011 and Attorney General Douglas Chen in 2015, both stating that criminal prosecutions may be brought against physicians who provide medical aid in dying. Specifically, Plaintiffs asked the Court to clarify that: (1) Hawaii’s murder and manslaughter statutes do not apply to medical aid in dying; (2) medical aid in dying is permitted by law; (3) medical aid in dying is not barred by Hawai‘i statutes; and (4) that physicians are permitted to provide medical aid in dying without fear of criminal prosecution.
On July 17, 2017, the court granted Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss, citing Kahaikapuna v. State of Hawai’i, 124 P.3d 975, in ruling that declaratory judgment for a criminal matter is not appropriate in this case. The court further opined that the court was ill suited to resolve this matter even if it could. On August 9, 2017, John Radcliffe, Charles Miller, M.D., and Compassion & Choices (“Plaintiffs-Appellants”) appealed the matter, bringing it to the Intermediate Court of Appeals of the State of Hawai’i.
Plaintiffs-Appellants re-argued their claims, and additionally stated that waiting on Hawaii’s legislative branch to consider the matter is not adequate, as the legislature has a “repeated failure to pass any law either expressly outlawing the practice, or setting forth in detail the procedures and safeguards by which medical aid in dying may be employed.” Plaintiffs-Appellants stated that there are numerous now-constitutional rights (gender, racial, etc.) that were pushed through judicially, rather than waiting for the legislature to address the matter.
However, Compassion & Choices’ efforts were not in vain. Our companion legislation brought in conjunction with the lawsuit was successful, and on April 5, 2018, Hawaii’s Governor, David Ige, signed the Our Care, Our Choice Act, which grants citizens of Hawai’i the ability to receive medical aid in dying beginning January 1, 2019! While the passing of the Our Care, Our Choice Act is a tremendous accomplishment for the citizens of Hawai’i, Radcliffe v. Hawai’i is still being litigated until the law goes into effect.